Languages:
Home » Power lines » Level 3 » Question 4

Electromagnetic fields from Power lines, Wiring & Appliances

4. Do Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) fields cause other health effects?

  • 4.1 Do ELF fields cause reproductive effects?
  • 4.2 Do ELF fields cause genetic and related effects?
  • 4.3 Do ELF fields cause other health effects in animals?
  • 4.4 Do ELF fields cause other health effects in humans?

4.1 Do ELF fields cause reproductive effects?

The source document for this Digest states:

Other relevant data

Reproductive effects in humans and animals

Taken as a whole, the results of human studies do not establish an association of adverse reproductive outcomes with exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields. Such adverse outcomes have been reported in a few studies, particularly at higher field intensities and in people exposed for longer durations. With exposures from video display terminals, a greater number of studies have been performed and these generally found no adverse reproductive effects.

Experiments with many different mammalian and non-mammalian experimental models consistently indicate lack of adverse effects on reproduction and development from exposure to strong static magnetic (0.25-1.0 T ) and ELF electric (up to 150 kV/m) fields. Static magnetic fields with high spatial gradients and those mixed with alternating fields have been reported to affect embryonic development in frogs and mice, although the number of studies is small.

Prenatal exposure to ELF magnetic fields generally does not result in adverse effects on reproduction and development in mammals. When effects are observed, they usually consist of minor developmental anomalies. Non-mammalian classes of animals (fish, frogs, birds) show inconsistent effects of ELF electric and magnetic fields on development (including increased malformations).

Source & ©: IARC Monograph Volume 80, " Non-Ionizing Radiation" (2002),
Part 1 Static and Extremely Low-Frequency (ELF) Electric and Magnetic Fields,
Chap. 5 Summary of Data Reported and Evaluation, section 5.4

4.2 Do ELF fields cause genetic and related effects?

The source document for this Digest states:

Genetic and related effects

A few studies on genetic effects have examined chromosomal aberrations and micronuclei in lymphocytes from workers exposed to ELF electric and magnetic fields. In these studies, confounding by genotoxic agents (tobacco, solvents) and comparability between the exposed and control groups are of concern. Thus, the studies reporting an increased frequency of chromosomal aberrations and micronuclei are difficult to interpret.

Many studies have been conducted to investigate the effects of ELF magnetic fields on various genetic end-points. Although increased DNA strand breaks have been reported in brain cells of exposed rodents, the results are inconclusive; most of the studies show no effects in mammalian cells exposed to magnetic fields alone at levels below 50 . However, extremely strong ELF magnetic fields have caused adverse genetic effects in some studies. In addition, several groups have reported that ELF magnetic fields enhance the effects of known DNA- and chromosome-damaging agents such as ionizing radiation.

The few animal studies on cancer-related non-genetic effects are inconclusive. Results on the effects on in-vitro cell proliferation and malignant transformation are inconsistent, but some studies suggest that ELF magnetic fields affect cell proliferation and modify cellular responses to other factors such as melatonin. An increase in apoptosis following exposure of various cell lines to ELF electric and magnetic fields has been reported in several studies with different exposure conditions. Numerous studies have investigated effects of ELF magnetic fields on cellular end-points associated with signal transduction, but the results are not consistent.

Source & ©: IARC Monograph Volume 80, " Non-Ionizing Radiation" (2002),
Part 1 Static and Extremely Low-Frequency (ELF) Electric and Magnetic Fields,
Chap. 5 Summary of Data Reported and Evaluation, section 5.4

4.3 Do ELF fields cause other health effects in animals?

The source document for this Digest states:

Other effects in animals

Studies to evaluate immune function and host resistance in animals have given negative effects for exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields. In-vitro exposure of immune system cells generally did not cause changes in proliferation capacity.

Apart from occasional changes in some haematological parameters in one rat Power Lines, no consistent effects on blood formation were seen in experimental animals or their offspring exposed to either static magnetic fields or to 50- or 60-Hz electric and/or magnetic fields.

Most animal studies of endocrine function concern the pineal gland and melatonin, because of concerns related to cancer. Fewer studies have been carried out on the effects of exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields on the pituitary hormones or those of other endocrine glands.

Some, but not all, studies of the effects of 50- or 60-Hz electric and magnetic fields in rodents show a reduction in pineal and/or serum melatonin concentrations. Differences in response have been reported for linearly polarized compared with circularly polarized magnetic fields. No convincing effect on melatonin concentrations has been seen in non-human primates chronically exposed to 50- or 60-Hz electric or magnetic fields.

With the possible exception of short-term stress (duration of minutes) following the onset of exposure to ELF electric fields at levels significantly above perception thresholds, no consistent effects have been seen in the stress-related hormones of the pituitary'adrenal axis in a variety of mammalian species.

Animals can perceive ELF electric fields (threshold 3-35 kV/m) and respond with activity changes or aversion. Such responses are generally not observed with magnetic fields.

Although exposure to magnetic fields has been reported to influence spatial learning and memory in rodents, it appears that no long-term behavioural deficits occur due to exposure to static or ELF electric and magnetic fields.

Source & ©: IARC Monograph Volume 80, " Non-Ionizing Radiation" (2002),
Part 1 Static and Extremely Low-Frequency (ELF) Electric and Magnetic Fields,
Chap. 5 Summary of Data Reported and Evaluation, section 5.4

4.4 Do ELF fields cause other health effects in humans?

The source document for this Digest states:

Other effects in humans

Due to the small number of immunological and haematological studies in humans and very small sample sizes within the reported studies, no health-related conclusions can be drawn from the data on immunological and haematological effects after exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields.

In humans, the principal element of neuroendocrine response to exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields that has been investigated is the circadian production and release of melatonin. No effect on melatonin was seen following night-time exposure of human volunteers to 50 or 60-Hz magnetic fields under controlled laboratory conditions. In contrast, a small reduction in melatonin concentration has been observed in occupational and residential environments, but it is difficult to distinguish between effects of the magnetic field and those of other environmental factors.

Apart from established perceptual responses in humans to ELF electric fields at levels of tens of kilovolts per meter and the occurrence of magnetophosphenes (faint, flickering visual sensations) in response to exposure to relatively strong ELF magnetic fields (> 10 at 20 Hz), few behavioural effects of exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields have been observed. Changes in electroencephalograms, cognition, mood, sleep electrophysiology and cardiac response tend to be few, subtle and transitory when they do occur during exposure. The evidence from epidemiological studies of residential and occupational exposure to ELF electric and magnetic fields in relation to the incidence of neurodegenerative disease, depression and suicide and cardiovascular disease is generally weak and inconsistent.

Source & ©: IARC Monograph Volume 80, " Non-Ionizing Radiation" (2002),
Part 1 Static and Extremely Low-Frequency (ELF) Electric and Magnetic Fields,
Chap. 5 Summary of Data Reported and Evaluation, section 5.4